Evaluation of Radiological Health Risk Associated with Indian Tiles Available in Nigerian Markets

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T Article history: Received: 10 September, 2020 Accepted: 11 February, 2021 Online: 28 May, 2021 Seven imported Indian tiles available in the Nigerian markets were investigated in this study to determine their radiological health hazards on users. Gamma spectroscopy was used for the analysis. The calculated radiological variables such as the dose rate, radium equivalent, internal and external hazard indices, gamma index, annual effective dose and the corresponding alpha index were used to determine the potential health risks on people exposed to these building tiles. The average activity concentration of Ra, Th and K were found to be 68.03, 84.79 and 620.89 Bq/kg respectively. These results were observed to be greater than the world recognized average safe boundary for building purposes. Similarly, the dose rate for all investigated tiles ranged between 59.14 and 154.65. This also revealed much higher values than the recommended standard except for GPI which recorded a lower result. However, the mean result of the radium activity equivalent in all the samples investigated was noted to be 237.09 Bq/kg. Both internal and external hazard indices reported much lower results than the recommended safe limit in all the tiles. Similarly, the gamma activity, the annual effective dose, and the alpha indices reported results that are within the safe limit. Therefore, it can be concluded that Indian tiles present in Nigerian market do not pose any health risk to users.


Introduction
One of the environmental challenges that is a concern in every part of the world is the exposure of man to radiation. The undue exposure of man to this radiation have been noted to result in adverse medical effect on human. [1]. Natural occurrences and man-made activities have had significant impacts on the level of radiation available in our environment. Therefore, satisfactory and acceptable information of the level of exposure from both man-made and natural radioactivity sources is very crucial. Researches have revealed that the earth crust is composed of different materials including materials that contain a relatively low concentration of naturally occurring radionuclides. It has also been noted in recent studies that water and soil polluted with radionuclides could be threats to the public health as well as the environment [2]. Further research revealed that the average standard for indoor effective dose due to gamma rays from building materials is about 0.4 mSv per annum [1] and [3]. The major contributors identified for exposures to radiation of natural sources include radioactive nuclides present in the earth's crust, natural radionuclides present in human body (taken in through diets) and cosmic ray particles incident on the earth [1]. People are more prone to radiation exposure by staying indoors as the radioactive materials are more concentrated indoor than outdoor. This is because naturally occurring radioactive materials are present in the crust, ceilings, floors and concrete walls of schools, homes, offices and malls, where occupants spend a lot of time [4] and [5]. Moreover, the concentration of the radioactive materials is more in an indoor environment, when the ventilation is poor.
Generally, building materials are made from rocks and soil, which originate from the earth crust, while some are developed from a mixture of industrial by products [6] and [7]. Therefore, ASTESJ ISSN: 2415-6698 they have very high tendency of containing more radioactive substances such as 238U and 232Th series and natural 40K, which are naturally part of the raw materials for building materials [3[, [5] and [8]. Also, every stage of construction of a building requires the use of soil or rocks and the land on which a building is sited constitute a major proportion of radioactive materials [9] and [10]. The foregone further established why the indoor concentration of these substances may be very high [9][10][11]. The availability of naturally occurring radioactive materials (NORMs) in building materials is the cause for the internal and external exposures of radiation to individuals staying in buildings [12][13][14][15][16]. Similarly plant cultivation and the introduction of various chemical fertilizers to aid the farming yield could expose consumers to more radiation. This is because the application of fertilizers to soil, used for farming purposes, may increase its radionuclide contents beyond proportion. Thus, man becomes unduly exposed when feeding on plants cultivated on these kind of lands because of exchange of nutrients between the soil and the plants [17]. Therefore, feeding on some of these plants, especially those that require more proportion of these chemical based fertilizers to germinate would expose man to radioactive substances.
Proper consideration of the above makes it clear that there is no escape for man from radiation exposure, the consolation is that adequate efforts must be made to control exposure so as to prevent the associated health risk. It is on this note that this research was conducted on the commonly purchased building tiles available in Nigeria so as to evaluate and ascertain the concentration of radionuclides in the tiles and also, to estimate the possible health risk of exposure to the people that are often in contact with them.

Preparation of Samples
Seven (7) different samples of tiles Indian branded tiles that are commonly available and purchased for building construction purposes in Nigerian markets were studied in this research ( Table  1). The tiles were transported to the geological laboratory at Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile Ife in Osun State Nigeria for preparation. The tiles were prepared by first labelling and assigning sample identity to each pack. Second on the line of preparation involved breaking all the tile samples into smaller pieces for the next stage of processing using the Pascall Engineering Lab milling machine. The samples were crushed to size that would be easy for pulverization. One of the precautions observed at this stage was that, the crusher or lab milling machine was adequately cleaned using a pressure blower (Wolf power tools, made in London with serial and type and numbers 978 A and 8793 respectively) after each tile sample was crushed to prevent erroneous mixture of the samples. Furthermore, each sample of crushed tiles was pulverized by completely grinding them into fine powder using the disk "grinder/pulverizer" by Christy and Norris Limited. As done with the crusher, the pulverizer was thoroughly cleaned and blown by a pressure blower, after each sample was grinded in order to avoid cross contamination of the samples. After this stage, a very fine powder of each sample was obtained, this was sieved using a 250 µm sieve size for the purpose of homogeneity. A measured quantity of 200 g of each sieved sample was first packaged in a high density polyethylene bottles (HDPB) before it was transferred to 500 mL size of Marinelli beakers for radioactivity study. The bottles had been earlier washed with detergent and thoroughly rinsed with ordinary water from borehole and finally rinsed with distilled water.

Gamma Spectrometric Analysis of the Selected Samples
The purchased samples of Indian tiles available in the Nigerian market were prepared in accordance to the IAEA TRS-295 [18]. The prepared samples were packaged in a plastic beaker container and were sealed for twenty-eight days for secular equilibrium, so that the parent radionuclide would be equal to the daughter. The samples were analyzed at the Nuclear laboratory of Universiti Malaysia with the use of High Purity Germanium detector using the approach engaged by [7] and [9][10][11].

Determination of Radioactivity Concentration
The radioactivity concentrations of 226 Ra, 232 Th, and 40 K for samples of produced in India and their corresponding average values are presented in Table 2.  [19] findings. The results slightly compares with [10], this may be as a result of the similarity in the regional geology of the areas where the raw materials were sourced. Equation (1), recommended and used by [20] and [1] was used to determine the absorbed dose rates from the obtained activity concentrations and the estimated results are shown in Table 3.
From the result presented in the Table below, it could be seen that all the results were far higher than the recommended standard of 80 nGy/h except for GPI which reported lower than the standard. The highest absorbed dose rate was reported in RBI while the lowest was noticed in GPI as presented in Table 3. The mean value of the absorbed dose rate was found to be 108.54 nGy/h. It could be seen that most of the Indian tiles available in Nigerian market have very high absorbed dose rate except for GPI, making the Indian tiles unsafe in this regard.
where ACRA, ACTh and ACK are the activities concentration of 226 Ra, 232 Th and 40 K measured in Bq/kg respectively. The results of the radium equivalent activity obtained for the available Indian tiles in Nigeria varied between 116.15 and 304.09 Bq/kg ( Table 3). The highest value of radium equivalent was noted in RBI while the lowest value was measured in GPI respectively. The average value of the activity concentration for radium equivalent was estimated to be 237.09 Bq/kg. In all, it was observed that for all the Indian tiles in Nigeria, their radium equivalent values were not above the accepted standard of 370 Bq/kg according to [12] and [20].

Calculation of External Hazard Index (Hex)
The radiation hazard index from gamma ray due to 226 Ra, 232 Th and 40 K could be estimated by equation (3) where, ARa , ATh and AK are the average values of the activity concentrations of 226 Ra, 232 Th and 40 K in Bq/kg respectively. The standard recommended for the Hex is a value less than 1 and at most equal to 1. From the result obtained, the Hex varied between 0.31 and 0.82 for both GPI and RBI respectively. In this case, all the available Indian tiles considered for this parameter had values that are acceptable and within the allowable standard ( Table 3). The estimated mean value of the Hex obtained is 0.64. Thus, the Indian tiles are regarded to be safe for use in building construction purposes as far as this health parameter is concerned [1] and [14].

Internal Hazard Index Estimation (Hin)
The internal hazard index is a measure of how much radiation an occupant of a confined setting is exposed to. This is represented by Hin and it can be calculated with equation (4) [21]: Hin = (ARa/185) + (ATh/259) + (AK/4810) ≤ 1 (4) where ARa, ATh and AK are activity concentrations of 226 Ra, 232 Th and 40 K, respectively in Bq/kg. For a building construction material to be regarded as safe, the hazard index from the radiation emitted from such materials must be within a standard limit of less than or equal to 1. The observed values of Hin for the Indian tiles in Nigeria were noted to range between 0.25 and 1.08 (Table 3).
The lowest value of Hin was reported by TBI while the highest value was noticed in RBI. BGI and RBI were noticed to be greater than the recommended world safe value of 1 among the Indian tiles investigated, which might be considered unsafe for internal usage purposes. The average value of the Hin was estimated to be 0.78, which is within the recommended standard for use in building materials. The results presented in Table 3 agreed with [7] and [11].

The Annual Effective Dose Rate (AEDR)
Equation (5) was used to estimate the AEDE received by occupants from the indoor internal dose rate according to [1].
The values of the AEDE ranged between 0.18 and 0.67 mSvy -1 with an average value of 0.50 mSvy -1 . The mean value from the Indian tiles being considered in this study was estimated to be lower than the world's recommended average value of 0.7 mSvy -1 [11]. The values of AEDR for each sample are presented in Table  4. The result obtained for AEDR in this study was observed to be higher than [9]. This is suspected to be as a result of difference in the geological formations of the materials used in the production of the tiles.

Gamma Index Estimation (Iγ)
This index is engaged to calculate the hazrd of γ-radiation because of the presence of natural radionuclide in the samples being investigated. The gamma index (Iγ) is evaluated using Equation (6) according to [22]. Iγ = CRa/300 (Bq/kg) + CTh/200 (Bq/kg) + CK/3000 (Bq/kg) The results obtained from the equation above for the Indian tile samples are presented below. A range of values between 0.29 and 1.10 were obtained from the calculation of the gamma index ( Table 4). The results revealed RBI to have the highest result with a value of 1.10 while TBI was noted to have the lowest result. The recommended safe limit for gamma index varied between 0.3 and 1 mSvy -1 , which is the extra gamma dose to the ones received outside of the building [23]. The calculated average Iγ obtained is 0.80, which is less than the restricted limit by international standard. Thus, building materials such as tiles should not be considered for radioactivity if the excess gamma radiation emanating from them increases the annual effective dose of a member of the public by 0.3 mSv at the most. Based on the recommended standard for gamma index, most of the Indian tiles in Nigeria are below the safety limit of 1 mSv except RBI (1.10) and BGI (1.07).

Determination of Alpha Index (Iα)
The estimation of the alpha index is another essential part of hazard measurement that quantifies the amount of alpha radiation due to radon inhalation that has its source from building materials. The alpha index for the Indian tiles was determined using equation (7) [24] and [25] is: where CRa (Bq/kg) is defined according to [26], [25] and [21]. The Table above shows the values of the estimated alpha index from the Indian tiles that are available in Nigeria. It is observed that the upper boundary of the concentration of radon (Iα) is same as 1 [27], [28] and [26]. In the present study, the obtained results revealed that the radon concentration varied from 0.06 to 0.49 with a mean value of 0.33. TBI reported the lowest result while the highest value was noticed in GSPPT. The results obtained from the alpha index are far less than the recommended value. This implies that the exhalation of radon from all the investigated Indian tiles would amount in indoor concentration that is lower than 200 Bq/kg.

Conclusion
Seven imported Indian tiles available in Nigerian markets were investigated in this study to determine their radiological health hazards on users. The estimated radiological parameters such as the dose rate, radium equivalent, internal and external hazard indices, gamma index, annual effective dose and the corresponding alpha activity index were used to determine the potential health risks on people exposed to these tiles. The mean activity concentrations of 226 Ra, 232 Th and 40 K were discovered to be 68.03, 84.79 and 620.89 Bq/kg respectively. These values reported higher than the recommended safe limit for building purposes. Similarly, the dose rate for tiles investigated ranged between 59.14 and 154.65. This revealed much higher values than the recommended standard except for GPI which recorded a lower result. However, the mean result of the radium activity equivalent in all the samples investigated was observed to be 237.09 Bq/kg and it is much lower than the recommended safe limit. In the same way, the result of the external index varied between 0.31 and 0.82. Likewise, the result of the internal hazard index ranged between 0.25 and 1.08, with an average value of 0.78. Moreover, the results of the annual effective dose were between 0.18 and 0.67. Finally, the gamma activity and the alpha indices were estimated, their average values were found to be 0.80 and 0.33 respectively. All the above results are within the recommended safe limit for building tiles. Generally, the dose rate for Indian tiles are far higher than the recommended safe standard, but all other radiological parameters prove that the tiles are safe to be used for construction purposes in Nigeria. However, similar investigation is recommended to be conducted regularly in order to ascertain the safety of Nigerian consumers that depend largely on imported goods.